KininarunoteA notebook of curious things

This site is only a doorway

Everything here is gathered from things other people actually researched, thought through, and built: books, papers, historical records, and the people behind them. If something here catches your interest, go look at the original sources listed at the bottom of the page. They carry more depth than a page like this ever can.

Where Do Birthday Parties, Cake, Candles, and the Birthday Song Come From?

Category: History & Culture

Cake, candles you blow out, and a song everyone knows: a birthday party feels as if it has always looked this way. It has not. One of the old birthday celebrations we can read about was for a king, and the song has a surprising story of its own, including a court case about who owned the words.

1. Old Birthdays: A King and Guardian Spirits

One of the oldest birthday celebrations on record is carved on the Rosetta Stone, made in Egypt in the 190s BC. The text is a decree from priests. It says that the 30th of the month Mesore is the day on which the birthday of the king, Ptolemy V, is celebrated [1]. It is one old example, not proof that this was the very first birthday party in the world.

That decree records a birthday celebration for a ruler. Ancient Rome had a different idea. Some Romans believed each person had a guardian spirit: a Genius for a man and a Juno for a woman. On the day of your birth, you honored it at the household shrine with prayers, vows, a wreath for its statue, and offerings such as incense, cakes, and wine [2]. So in Rome an ordinary person could have a birthday too.

The story did not run in a straight line. Early Christians often saw birthday celebrations as a pagan custom, and the writer Origen urged them to avoid them [2]. Birthdays came back later, though the sources I could read do not say exactly when or how quickly. So when did the cake and candles appear?

2. When Did Cake and Candles Join the Party?

The link between cake and birthdays may go back to Rome, where round cakes of flour, nuts, and honey were sometimes served at special birthdays and weddings. Those were not the cake you know today [3].

The candle story is easier to point to. In Germany in 1746, Count Ludwig von Zinzendorf had a birthday party in the town of Marienborn. His cake is said to have been as big as an oven could make it, with candles stuck in it to mark the years of his age [3]. That is a well-known early example, but it is one record, not a proof that candles on cakes began there. The sources I could read tell the account without a detailed original record, so treat the details as “said to be.”

Birthday cakes were part of birthday celebrations in Western Europe by at least the middle of the 19th century [3]. These examples come from different times, and the sources I could read do not show a continuous path from them to today’s custom. Cake and candles do not seem to have been invented all at once.

3. How a Classroom Greeting Became the Birthday Song

Now the song. Its melody comes from a different song, “Good Morning to All,” traditionally credited to the American sisters Patty and Mildred Hill, who published it in 1893. Patty Hill ran a kindergarten in Louisville, Kentucky, and Mildred was a pianist and composer. They wanted a tune that young children would find easy to sing [4].

Whether the sisters really composed the tune is disputed [4]. What is clearer is the timeline. Birthday-style words and the melody were first printed together in 1912, and the early printings carried no author credit [4]. A simple way to picture how it spread is a classroom: teachers and children changed the morning greeting into a birthday greeting. That picture is my own explanation, not a documented event.

4. Who Owned the Birthday Song? A Court Case

Because the song is so famous, a company called Warner/Chappell Music collected license fees when it was used in films and shows. In 2015, a federal court in California ruled on a case about that claim. The court held that the company had never acquired a valid copyright to the lyrics. The agreement with the Hill sisters’ publisher had covered piano arrangements of the melody, not the words [5].

The melody had long been in the public domain, so its copyright no longer restricted people from using it. A later settlement in 2016 is reported to have ended the company’s claim and required it to pay back about $14 million in fees [4]. The court did not decide who actually wrote the words [5]. This is a United States ruling, and other countries have their own copyright laws.

5. How You Can Look Into Birthdays Yourself

Ask a parent, grandparent, or neighbor what their birthdays were like as a child. Did they have a cake? Candles? Did anyone sing, and which song? Write down the answers with the year, then compare them. You may find that traditions differ by family, place, and decade.

If you use candles on a birthday cake, have an adult nearby, keep hair and sleeves away from the flames, and blow them out before anything else is lit.

Sources

Facts were compared across the sources below. Four of the five are not primary sources, and the Wikipedia articles were used only for items that are also in the other sources or are clearly marked as reported.

  1. Fordham University, Internet Ancient History Sourcebook, “The Rosetta Stone: Translation of the Greek Section” https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/ancient/rosetta-stone-translation.asp (Read the page text. It mentions the king’s birthday on the 30th of Mesore. The page gave no BC year, so I wrote only “the 190s BC” from general knowledge of the stone.)
  2. Wikipedia, “Birthday” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birthday (Read through a fetch tool that summarized the page. Source of the Genius custom and Origen. The origin of these claims was not checked, so I describe them in general terms.)
  3. Wikipedia, “Birthday cake” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birthday_cake (Read the opening part. Source of the Roman cakes and the 1746 Marienborn party. It is the only source for the 1746 account, so the claim is hedged.)
  4. Wikipedia, “Happy Birthday to You” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_Birthday_to_You (Read the opening part. Source of the 1893 and 1912 dates, the disputed authorship, and the 2016 repayment of $14 million.)
  5. Loeb & Loeb LLP, “Rupa Marya v. Warner/Chappell Music, Inc.” (2015) https://www.loeb.com/en/insights/publications/2015/10/rupa-marya-v-warnerchappell-music-inc (Law firm summary, read in full. I could not read the court order itself, which is a PDF, so details come through this summary.)