This site is only a doorway

Everything here is gathered from things other people actually researched, thought through, and built: books, papers, historical records, and the people behind them. If something here catches your interest, go look at the original sources listed at the bottom of the page. They carry more depth than a page like this ever can.

Is Dialect Just "Broken" Language? How Japan Came to Have a Standard Way of Speaking

Category: History & Culture

When you hear "Kansai-ben" or "Tohoku-ben," the different sounds can feel fun and lively. But behind these differences lies a very old secret. [1]

Are regional dialects really just "broken" versions of proper speech? Or do they hold onto history that standard language has lost? Let’s look at the facts behind the sounds of Japan. [2]

1. How Standard Japanese Began as a Local Dialect of Old Edo

Today’s "standard Japanese" actually began as the language spoken in the "Yamanote" area of old Edo (now Tokyo). [1] This area was home to many samurai. The language that developed there is thought to be a mix of samurai speech and the older language from the capital city of Kyoto. [1]

This means that what we now call "standard" was originally just one region’s dialect. It was not the "correct" language from the start, but a specific local way of speaking that eventually became the national norm. [1]

2. Why Kansai Dialect Might Be Older Than Standard Japanese

Kansai dialect has a unique rhythm that many people find enjoyable. Words like "nande yanen" (why?), "akan" (no good), and "honma ni" (really) are famous examples. [2] Even the word "meccha" (very), which is now used all over Japan, started as a Kansai word. [2]

There is a theory that the way Kansai speakers change the pitch of their words (accent) preserves an older form of Japanese. [2] It is thought that the Tokyo accent, which became the standard, may have changed later. [2] This means the Tokyo accent might be a newer development, while the Kansai accent kept older patterns. [2]

3. What Really Shaped the Sounds of Tohoku Speech

In the Tohoku region, some people speak in a way called "zu-zu-ben." [3] In this style, speakers do not strongly distinguish between the sounds "shi" and "su," or "chi" and "tsu." [3] You might have heard the phrase "je-je-je" from a 2013 TV drama; it comes from the Iwate prefecture dialect. [3]

Some people say Tohoku speakers talk this way because it is cold, so they do not open their mouths as much. [3] However, language researchers are not sure this is true. [3] Another theory is that people changed their sounds to make speaking easier and to use less energy. [3] So, there are doubts about the idea that cold weather is the cause. [3]

4. Why the Meiji Government Wanted Everyone to Speak the Same Way

During the Meiji era, the government decided that everyone in Japan should speak the same language. [4] If people spoke different dialects, it was hard to study in schools or read newspapers together. [4]

A scholar named Ueda Kazutoshi played a leading role in this effort. [4] He worked to establish standard Japanese and spread it through the school system. [4] This was a big change for a country that had many different regional ways of speaking. [4]

5. How Children Were Punished for Speaking Dialects in Okinawa

In some places, this push for standard language led to harsh rules. In Okinawa, there was a system called "dialect tags." [5] If a child spoke the local language at school, they had to wear a wooden tag around their neck. [5] This was not a game; it was a serious punishment. [5]

In 1939, this practice became even stricter in Okinawa and was also used in the Amami Islands. [5]

6. How Local Languages Are Being Valued Again Today

After World War II, television and radio became common. [6] People heard standard Japanese every day, so they learned it naturally. [6] Because of this, systems like the dialect tags were no longer needed and slowly disappeared. [6]

Now, the thinking has changed. People want to protect and value local languages. [6] In March 2006, Okinawa Prefecture made a rule that September 18 is "Shimakutuba Day." [6] It shows that local dialects are now seen as treasures, not mistakes. [6]

7. How Other Countries Have Standard and Local Speech Too

This struggle between standard and local speech is not just in Japan. In the United Kingdom, there is a "model" way of speaking called Received Pronunciation. [7] However, very few people actually speak this way in daily life. [7]

Meanwhile, in London, there is a distinct accent called "Cockney." [7] It has its own special phrases and rhyming slang. [7] Just like in Japan, there is a mix of a "standard" accent and lively local ways of speaking. [7]

8. Why You Should Listen to How People Around You Speak

Next time you hear someone speak differently, listen closely. [2] If you have grandparents or friends from other places, try to find the words they use that are different from yours. [2] You might discover that their way of speaking is actually older than the standard language you use every day. [2]

Sources

  1. Wikipedia "Yamanote Kotoba", Sophia University (SISU) "Tokyo Dialect and Standard Japanese" https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%B1%B1%E3%81%AE%E6%89%8B%E8%A8%80%E8%91%89 https://ja.shisu.edu.cn/resources/features/content14547 (Explains that current standard Japanese derives from Edo's Yamanote area and is said to be a mix of samurai and Kyoto language.)
  2. Wikipedia "Keihan Accent", Weekly Josei PRIME https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E4%BA%AC%E9%98%AA%E5%BC%8F%E3%82%A2%E3%82%AF%E3%82%BB%E3%83%B3%E3%83%88 https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E6%97%A5%E6%9C%AC%E8%AA%9E%E3%81%AE%E6%96%B9%E8%A8%80%E3%81%AE%E3%82%A2%E3%82%AF%E3%82%BB%E3%83%B3%E3%83%88 https://www.jprime.jp/articles/-/25980?page=2 (Notes that Kansai accent may preserve older forms than Tokyo accent, and that "meccha" spread nationwide from Kansai.)
  3. Wikipedia "Zuzu-ben", note.com, NEWS Post Seven https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E3%82%BA%E3%83%BC%E3%82%BA%E3%83%BC%E5%BC%81 https://note.com/yearman/n/n8ca016aa1b1a https://www.news-postseven.com/archives/20130429_184526.html (Describes Tohoku's "zu-zu-ben" sound merging, doubts the "cold weather" theory, and notes "je-je-je" is from Iwate but rarely used by locals.)
  4. Wikipedia "Ueda Kazutoshi", National Diet Library https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E4%B8%8A%E7%94%B0%E8%90%AC%E5%B9%B4 https://www.ndl.go.jp/portrait/datas/6110 (States the Meiji government sought standard language for national unity, with Ueda Kazutoshi playing a key role in its establishment.)
  5. Shimakutuba Juku Chimugukuru https://www.okinawa.bunkaju.jp/gallery/simakutuba003/ (Details the "dialect tag" punishment in Okinawa and Amami schools, where children wore tags for speaking local language, intensified in 1939.)
  6. Shimakutuba Juku Chimugukuru, Okinawa Prefectural Archives https://www.okinawa.bunkaju.jp/gallery/simakutuba003/ https://www.archives.pref.okinawa.jp/news/that_day/4940 (Explains how media spread standard Japanese, ending dialect tags, and notes the 2006 ordinance establishing "Shimakutuba Day".)
  7. Bizmates Blog, Duolingo Blog https://www.bizmates.jp/blog/english-dialect/ https://blog.duolingo.com/ja/global-dialects-english/ (Mentions UK's "Received Pronunciation" as a rare standard and London's "Cockney" dialect with unique slang.)