This site is only a doorway

Everything here is gathered from things other people actually researched, thought through, and built: books, papers, historical records, and the people behind them. If something here catches your interest, go look at the original sources listed at the bottom of the page. They carry more depth than a page like this ever can.

Who Really Found Halley’s Comet: The Farmer Who Saw It First or the Astronomer Who Predicted It?

Category: Space & Astronomy

On Christmas night in 1758, a German farmer looked up at the night sky and found a comet that the world had been waiting for. The man who had predicted its return, Edmond Halley, had died sixteen years earlier. How could he predict a year he would not live to see? And why did the comet take the name of the predictor, not the discoverer? This article traces the basis of the prediction and how accurate it was, leading back to measurements of southern stars and plans for observing Venus.

1. How Farmer Johann Georg Palitzsch Spotted the Comet on Christmas 1758

Johann Georg Palitzsch was a German farmer who loved observing celestial objects as an amateur astronomer. On the night of December 25, 1758, he spotted a faint light through his telescope. Three days later, on December 28, another observer named Hoffmann confirmed the sighting [3]. Palitzsch was not a scholar at a university or an observatory. Yet, the person who found the light that astronomers around the world were waiting for was a farmer who knew the night sky well. So why did everyone know the comet would return in this specific year?

2. How Halley Showed That the Comets of 1531, 1607 and 1682 Were One Comet

Edmond Halley studied records of past comets and compared their orbits. He found that the comets seen in 1531, 1607, and 1682 had nearly identical orbital paths around the Sun [2]. Comet orbits are usually different from one another. Halley judged that it was unlikely for three comets to be similar by chance. He concluded that this was the same object returning every 76 years, with the next return due around 1758. He published this conclusion in his 1705 book, *Synopsis of the Astronomy of Comets* [2]. Halley did not discover the comet itself. His achievement was noticing that past records showed a return and predicting the next year. It is reported that he wrote something to this effect: if the comet appeared around 1758, later generations would acknowledge that the first to notice this was an Englishman [4].

3. How Accurate Was Halley’s Prediction of the Comet’s Return?

Halley’s prediction had a range of uncertainty. This was because he had only roughly estimated the effect of the gravitational pull of Jupiter and Saturn on the comet’s movement [2]. After Halley’s death, three French astronomers—Clairaut, Lalande, and Lepaute—recalculated the comet’s path, taking these gravitational effects into account. They predicted the perihelion (the point closest to the Sun) would occur in mid-April 1759, with an error of about one month. The actual passage occurred earlier than this refined prediction [2]. The period is not exactly 76 years every time. The average is about 76 years, but it actually varies between approximately 74 and 79 years. This variation is attributed to the gravitational pull of Jupiter and Saturn, as well as the effect of gas emanating from the comet [2]. The prediction was correct, but the accuracy was improved by calculation.

4. Why the Comet Is Named After Halley, Not the People Who Saw It First

People had seen Halley’s Comet long before Halley himself. The oldest reliable record is said to be in the Chinese historical text *Shiji*, describing a record associated with Halley’s Comet in 240 BC. NASA links this to observations going back more than 2,000 years [1]. Despite this, the comet is named after Halley. According to NASA, this is because he was the first to predict its return, and that prediction was the first successful example of its kind [1]. The French astronomer Lacaille proposed the name in 1759, helping it catch on [2]. Thus, the name belongs to the person who predicted its return, not the person who found it.

5. How Halley Measured Southern Stars on Saint Helena at Age 20

At around age 20, Halley left Oxford for Saint Helena, a remote island in the Atlantic Ocean. This was because stars in the southern sky were difficult to see from Britain. Sources differ on whether he arrived in 1676 or 1677 [5]. There, he measured star positions and published a star catalog called *A Catalogue of the South-Heaven Stars* in 1679, listing 341 stars. This work was done with support from King Charles II and cooperation from the East India Company [5]. In October 1677, he also observed Mercury transit the Sun. It is said that he realized on this island that if the same phenomenon could be observed for Venus, it would be possible to measure the size of the solar system. However, this specific detail is based on summaries of search results [5].

6. Halley’s 1716 Plan to Use Venus to Measure the Distance From Earth to the Sun

In 1716, Halley proposed in the academic journal *Philosophical Transactions* that the distance between Earth and the Sun (the astronomical unit) could be calculated if the transit of Venus across the Sun were observed from widely separated locations [6]. The transits took place in 1761 and 1769. Halley became the Astronomer Royal (succeeding John Flamsteed) in 1720 and served until his death at age 85 in 1742, but he never saw these transits [6]. His predictions and proposals were directed toward a future he would not see. In 1769, Captain Cook observed the transit in Tahiti [6].

7. How to Work Out How Many Years Until the Comet Returns in 2061

The next perihelion passage of Halley’s Comet is expected in 2061 [1]. You can calculate how many years away that is by subtracting the current year from 2061. Try imagining your age at that time, considering your birthday. During the 1986 return, the European Giotto probe and others approached the nucleus, which was about 15 km × 8 km in size [1]. You might look for books or exhibits about comets at libraries or science museums. If you know an adult who remembers the 1986 Halley’s Comet, ask them what it was like. For official information, check the NASA page for 1P/Halley or explanations from the National Astronomical Observatory of Japan to confirm the date and viewing conditions for the next return. Verify predicted dates with new materials. To observe the sky as Palitzsch did, try observing the sky regularly. Observe from a safe place, together with an adult. Even without a telescope, you can record the moon’s position at the same time each night and compare it after a few days to see the movement of the sky.

Sources

  1. NASA Science, "1P/Halley" https://science.nasa.gov/solar-system/comets/1p-halley/ (NASA explains the origin of the name, the orbital period, historical records, and the 1986 observations.)
  2. Wikipedia, "Halley's Comet" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halley%27s_Comet (Wikipedia details the 1705 prediction, gravitational calculations, the range of the period, and the naming history.)
  3. Wikipedia, "Johann Georg Palitzsch" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johann_Georg_Palitzsch (Wikipedia covers the rediscovery of the comet in 1758 by Palitzsch.)
  4. Encyclopedia.com, "Halley, Edmond" https://www.encyclopedia.com/people/science-and-technology/astronomy-biographies/edmond-halley (Encyclopedia.com provides the gist of Halley's words regarding future recognition.)
  5. Royal Museums Greenwich, "Halley's visit to Saint Helena" https://rmg.co.uk/collections/archive/rmgc-object-574504 (The Royal Museums Greenwich describe Halley's observations and star catalog on Saint Helena.)
  6. Wikipedia, "Edmond Halley" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edmond_Halley (Wikipedia outlines Halley's proposal for observing Venus transits, his role as Astronomer Royal, and his death year.)