This site is only a doorway

Everything here is gathered from things other people actually researched, thought through, and built: books, papers, historical records, and the people behind them. If something here catches your interest, go look at the original sources listed at the bottom of the page. They carry more depth than a page like this ever can.

Are Horsetail Shoots and Green Horsetails the Same Plant?

Category: Living Things

In spring, the shoot you find on an embankment looks like a different weed from the horsetail. However, according to sources, this shoot is actually part of the horsetail, specifically a stem made to produce spores [1]. Moreover, it is often connected underground to the green stems of the horsetail. What is the green powder inside the head? How does it ride the wind using "threads" that shrink when wet and spread when dry? Why does the horsetail appear every year even after the shoot dies? Reading from the journey of the spores to the connections under the ground reveals why you meet them again each year.

2. Why the Powder from a Horsetail Shoot Is Spores, Not Seeds

This powder consists of spores. The horsetail is a fern in the Equisetaceae family, and ferns do not produce flowers or seeds. Instead, they increase their numbers using spores [3]. This is a different path from plants that reproduce by flowering and making seeds. If you consider the shoot as a stem created to produce and send out these spores, the meaning of the hexagons packed tightly in the head becomes clear. By the way, spores are light, like powder. If they simply fall at the base of the parent plant without being carried by the wind, they cannot spread far. Is there some mechanism to help them?

Perhaps the spores themselves have a mechanism that makes them easier to fly.

3. How the Threads on Horsetail Spores Move with Humidity

Spores have thin, string-like parts called elaters, which stretch and shrink according to humidity [4]. They shrink when there is moisture and spread out when it is dry [2]. The explanation in the sources is that by spreading out on a dry, sunny day, they become easier to catch on the wind [2]. When the air is humid, they curl up; when it is dry, they spread. If you want to disperse spores, a dry, sunny day seems more suitable. We will not count how many elaters each spore has here.

4. How a Fallen Horsetail Spore Becomes a Small Prothallus

A spore that rides the wind and falls to the ground does not immediately become a horsetail. First, it becomes a small body called a prothallus. The prothallus has male and female organs, and fertilization occurs there for the first time. After that, the body of the next horsetail grows [3]. The spore-bearing shoot, having finished releasing its spores, ends its role and withers [3]. However, the horsetail appears in the same place the year after it withered. Why does it come out every year even if the shoot dies?

If the withered shoot were the only thing to rely on, this would not make sense.

6. Why Horsetail Is Hard to Control in Fields

The underground stems of the horsetail can extend long and sideways beneath the ground. Even if the above-ground parts are removed, if stems remain underground, new shoots may emerge from there. Because the underground stems can sometimes increase even when cut apart, they are often treated as a difficult weed to handle in fields. Hidden beneath the cute shoot that peeks out in early spring is this strong system. On the other hand, living underground stems help it return each year.

7. Where You Can See Fossils of Carboniferous Sphenopsids

Materials from the Gunma Prefectural Museum of Natural History feature actual fossils of sphenopsids from the Carboniferous period of the Paleozoic era [5]. The same materials explain that the genus Equisetum is the only genus within the class Equisetopsida that is still living today [5]. However, from this material, one cannot say that the current horsetail is the same as the plants from the Carboniferous period, or that it is a direct descendant of sphenopsids.

8. What You Can Investigate Next About Horsetail Shoots

Comparing the state of shoot heads is one way to investigate. If the head is closed, the spores are still inside. If it is fully open, the spores have already flown away [2]. If you compare several in the same place, you might see differences in how far the dispersal has progressed. The speed at which shoots grow and the photosynthesis of the green horsetail stems are questions not covered in this article. There is room for you to check these yourself by looking at encyclopedias or museum exhibits.

Sources

  1. Sapporo City Museum Activity Center, "Tsukushi and Sugina" https://www.city.sapporo.jp/museum/ouchimuseum/0502.html (Explains the connection between bamboo shoots and horsetails, and the timing of their appearance.)
  2. Miyagi Prefectural Comprehensive Education Center, "Tsukushi and Sugina" https://www.edu-c.pref.miyagi.jp/midori/science/kagaku-junkai/junkaikyouzai/tukushi.pdf (Covers head observation, elaters, origin of names, and methods of reproduction.)
  3. National Institute of Biomedical Innovation, Health and Nutrition, "That's Kitto" March 2020 https://www.nibiohn.go.jp/eiken/info/pdf/k266.pdf (Explains fern reproduction and the prothallus stage.)
  4. Wikipedia, "Sugina" https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/スギナ (Details the structure of elaters.)
  5. Gunma Prefectural Museum of Natural History, "Various Fossils" https://www.gmnh.pref.gunma.jp/wp-content/uploads/01_iroironakaseki.pdf (Features fossils of sphenopsids.)