This site is only a doorway

Everything here is gathered from things other people actually researched, thought through, and built: books, papers, historical records, and the people behind them. If something here catches your interest, go look at the original sources listed at the bottom of the page. They carry more depth than a page like this ever can.

How Did Scientists First Grow Tetanus Germs All by Themselves?

Category: The Body

Tetanus, sometimes called lockjaw, is caused by a germ that lives in soil. To prove that one particular germ causes a disease, scientists need to grow it alone, with no other germs mixed in. For tetanus this was said to be so hard that some researchers had concluded it could not be done [1]. In 1889, in Robert Koch's laboratory in Berlin, a Japanese doctor named Kitasato Shibasaburō (in Japan the family name comes first) succeeded, with his coworkers. The short answer: he used two of the germ's own quirks against it, its tough resting form and its dislike of air.

1. Why a germ that is always mixed with other germs was so hard to isolate

Tetanus germs, Clostridium tetani, are found in soil, ash and animal droppings, so a wound that picks up dirt picks up a crowd of different germs, too [2]. Scientists in the 1880s wanted to know which germ in the crowd caused the stiff, painful muscle spasms. The test is to grow a single kind of germ by itself, which is called a pure culture, and see whether it alone can cause the disease. Before Kitasato's work, tetanus germs had been reported only in mixed cultures, together with other germs [1]. It is also an "anaerobe," meaning it does not grow where there is ordinary air. So how do you remove the unwanted germs without killing the one you want?

2. How heating a mixed sample left only the tetanus germs alive

Tetanus germs can curl up into tough, dormant forms called spores. A spore is a bit like a seed: it can sit through hard times and wake up later. The spores of this germ resist heat very well. Even today the World Health Organization notes that they resist heat and most antiseptics and can survive in the environment for years [2]. According to a standard biography reference, Kitasato heated a mixed culture at 80°C (176°F) for 45 to 60 minutes. The heating was reported to weaken or kill many germs without spores, while the tetanus spores could still grow afterward [1]. Heating was not meant to wipe everything out. It worked as a filter that let one kind of germ through, and that is the clever part. Those exact numbers come from a secondary source, not from his original 1889 paper, so treat them as the reported method rather than a recipe.

3. How replacing air with hydrogen let an air-hating germ grow

Heat solved only half the problem. The survivors still would not grow in open air. Kitasato had already shown, working on a related air-hating germ that causes a cattle disease, that such germs could grow on a solid surface surrounded by hydrogen gas [1]. For tetanus he grew the heated sample in a hydrogen atmosphere, and the result was the first pure culture of Clostridium tetani [1]. Neither trick would have been enough alone. Heat chose the right germ, and hydrogen gave it a place to grow. Once there was a pure culture, a new question could be asked: what exactly does this germ do to the body?

4. How a pure culture revealed a poison, and a blood serum that could cancel it

With the germ grown alone, Kitasato could study the liquid it left behind. He studied the poison it makes, a toxin. The secondary source reports that animals given gradually larger doses of the toxin later survived doses that would otherwise kill them, that the serum (the clear part of the blood) of these animals could cancel the toxin, and that it could also help other animals that were not protected [1]. In 1890 he and Emil von Behring published a paper together on immunity to diphtheria and tetanus. Behring wrote the diphtheria part and Kitasato wrote most of the tetanus part [1]. This idea of treating an illness with the antibodies of an immune animal is called serum therapy. The details of the animal experiments come from the same secondary source, so for exact numbers and dates, the 1890 paper itself is the place to look.

5. Why the first Nobel Prize for this idea went to Behring alone

The first Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine, in 1901, went to Behring alone, "for his work on serum therapy, especially its application against diphtheria" [3]. Kitasato did not receive one. Many people have wondered why. Some accounts say the practice of sharing a prize among several people was not yet common, but the sources I could read do not settle the reason, so it remains a guess. What the record does show is that Behring's prize was for diphtheria, and that the tetanus work began with a pure culture that Kitasato had made.

6. How tetanus spores in soil connect to your vaccine record today

The spores Kitasato learned to handle can still be found in soil around the world. Tetanus does not spread from person to person. It begins when spores get into a cut or wound [2]. Vaccines made with an inactivated form of the toxin, called toxoid, prevent it, and the WHO recommends a first series of doses followed by boosters; the schedule depends on age and vaccination history [2]. People who recover from tetanus do not become immune, so they still need the vaccine [2]. The WHO reports that deaths of newborns from tetanus fell by 84% between 2000 and 2021, to just over 7,700, largely because of vaccination [2]. If you get a dirty wound, tell a grown-up. They can help clean it and check whether you need medical advice about tetanus.

7. A question to take further: what else could one changed condition reveal?

Kitasato did not find a new germ. He changed the conditions, first temperature and then air, until one germ was left standing. You can look for the same idea elsewhere: when something is hard to study, which one condition could you change? Ask a grown-up to help you find one thing you want to know in the WHO tetanus fact sheet [2], and if you want to go deeper, the 1901 Nobel Prize pages [3] are a good place to start.

Sources

  1. Encyclopedia.com, "Kitasato, Shibasaburo" (from the Dictionary of Scientific Biography) https://www.encyclopedia.com/people/medicine/medicine-biographies/shibasaburo-kitasato (Read the main text through the 1890 paper and plague work. Source of the 1889 pure culture, the 80°C and 45 to 60 minute heating, hydrogen, the toxin and antitoxin work. It is a secondary source; Kitasato's original papers were not read, so the heating figures and animal-experiment details were not checked against them.)
  2. World Health Organization, "Tetanus" fact sheet https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/tetanus (Read the key facts, overview, treatment and prevention sections. Source of the spores in soil, heat resistance, no person-to-person spread, vaccination schedule and the neonatal tetanus figures for 2000 and 2021.)
  3. NobelPrize.org, "The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1901" and "Emil von Behring – Facts" https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1901/summary/ (Read in full. Source of the prize motivation and the sole share. Why Kitasato did not share the prize is not explained there.)