This site is only a doorway

Everything here is gathered from things other people actually researched, thought through, and built: books, papers, historical records, and the people behind them. If something here catches your interest, go look at the original sources listed at the bottom of the page. They carry more depth than a page like this ever can.

Why Does High Tide Come About 50 Minutes Later Each Day?

Category: Sea & Fishing

Print out a tide table for any seaside town and compare two days. If high tide is at 6:00 in the morning today, the table says tomorrow's is close to 6:50. The day after, close to 7:40. The clock on the wall says each day is 24 hours, so what is the sea keeping time with?

The answer sits in the sky, and it took people a long time to agree on it. This article follows that 50-minute shift to the Moon, asks why the sea rises on two sides of the Earth at once, and shows where the simple picture stops working. A short side note at the end covers a famous wrong turn by Galileo.

1. High tide comes about 50 minutes later each day, just as the Moon does

Most coasts get two high tides and two low tides in a stretch of 24 hours and 50 minutes, with high tides about 12 hours and 25 minutes apart[1]. Those 24 hours and 50 minutes are called a lunar day (or tidal day): the time it takes a spot on Earth to turn from "directly under the Moon" to "directly under the Moon" again.

A lunar day is longer than a normal day because the Moon is moving too. It circles the Earth in the same direction the Earth spins, so after one full spin the Moon has crept ahead, and the Earth needs about 50 extra minutes to catch up[1]. The tides do not follow the Sun's clock. They mainly follow the Moon.

That is a strong hint, but a hint is not an explanation. How can a faraway Moon move the whole sea, and why can it raise water on both the side facing it and the side facing away?

2. The Moon pulls harder on the near side of the Earth than the far side, and that difference raises two bulges of water

Here is the surprising part. A tide does not come from the Moon's pull alone. It comes from the difference in that pull from one place on Earth to another[2]. The Moon's pull is a little stronger on the half of the Earth facing it, because that half is closer, and a little weaker on the far half.

A simple way to picture it is three dots in a line: one on the near side of Earth, one at its center, and one on the far side. The Moon pulls the near-side dot a little more strongly than the center dot, and the far-side dot a little less strongly. That difference stretches Earth very slightly along the line to the Moon. The far-side water is pulled less than Earth's center, so it is left behind as Earth is stretched. The solid ground barely gives, but the ocean is free to move, so water gathers into one bulge facing the Moon and a second bulge on the opposite side. NOAA's explanation says this stretching and squashing is what makes the two tidal bulges[2].

At the edges of a bulge, part of the Moon's pull acts along the sea surface. It nudges water toward the places directly under the Moon and on the opposite side of Earth[3].

Now go back to section 1. The Earth turns once a day, carrying you through both bulges, so you meet a high tide twice per lunar day. A bulge is not a wave sweeping across the sea. It is the sea's shape, held roughly in place by the Moon, while the coast spins through it.

The Sun makes tides in the same way. It is far bigger but much farther away, and its tide-making force comes out at about half the Moon's, or a bit less, depending on which source you use[1][3].

3. Real tides are not two neat bulges: the Moon's phase and the shape of the coast and sea floor change them

Twice a month, at new moon and full moon, the Sun, Earth, and Moon line up, and the Sun's tide adds to the Moon's. That produces extra-high high tides and very low low tides, called spring tides. (The name has nothing to do with the season.) At the half-moon stages, when the Moon looks half lit, the Sun and Moon pull from directions at right angles. Their tide-making effects partly cancel, making smaller tides called neap tides[1]. Tides also get a little bigger when the Moon is at the closest point of its orbit[1].

Place matters as much as the Moon. If Earth were smooth and covered with water, the bulges would sweep around evenly. Real oceans have continents and basins of all depths in the way, so tides can be small in one place and dramatic in another[2][3]. The highest tides in the world are in Canada's Bay of Fundy[4], where the difference between high and low water is roughly 15 meters (about 50 feet). In the open ocean, the difference is around 1 meter (3 feet), as a rough estimate[5]. The Moon's pull in the Bay of Fundy is the same as anywhere else. The shape of the coast and the sea floor does the rest.

So the tide table on your wall is an answer to three questions at once: where the Moon is, where the Sun is, and what the local coast does with the water.

Side note: Galileo explained the tides without the Moon, and his idea did not fit the tide tables

Not everyone saw the Moon connection as obvious. Johannes Kepler had suggested it, but Galileo Galilei turned it down: a pull reaching across empty space looked to him like a mysterious influence[6]. In his 1632 Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems he argued instead that the Earth's spin and its yearly circling of the Sun combine, so the seas slosh back and forth like water in a pushed bowl[6]. The account I read says this matched the observed tides poorly[6], and a sloshing tied to the Earth's daily motion has no obvious way to produce the 50-minute shift from section 1.

The Moon's pull was put on firm ground by Isaac Newton's Principia (1687), which set out a law of gravity: every piece of matter pulls on every other, more weakly the farther apart they are. Tide theory has built on it ever since[7].

How to check the 50-minute shift yourself

  • Catch the 50-minute shift. Find a free online tide table for any coast (a national weather or ocean agency, or a local harbor site). Write down the time of the first high tide on five days in a row. Is each one about 50 minutes later than the one before? Now look at the day-to-day change on a different coast and compare.
  • Tides and the Moon's phase. Next to your notes, write down the phase of the Moon on each day, from a calendar. Around new moon and full moon, is the gap between high and low tide bigger than at the half moon? Then you have found spring and neap tides in the table.
  • Visiting the shore. Go with an adult, check the tide times first, and stay on safe, higher ground. A beach that is wide and open now can be much smaller in a few hours.
  • Read the original. NOAA's tides tutorial has short pages on each idea above. Compare its explanation of the two bulges with the one in section 2.

Sources

This article is a personal summary based on the public sources listed below.

  1. NOAA National Ocean Service, "Tides and Water Levels" tutorial (pages on the lunar day, tidal variations, and tide-generating forces). https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/education/tutorial_tides/tides05_lunarday.html (The lunar day page and the variations page, https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/education/tutorial_tides/tides06_variations.html, were read in full. The 24 hours 50 minutes, the 12 hours 25 minutes, spring and neap tides, and the closest-point effect come from them. The tutorial's gravity page explains the far-side bulge with "inertia" instead of differential gravity; this article uses the explanation in sources 2 and 3 instead. The tutorial says the Sun's force is "about half" the Moon's, while source 3 gives the Moon as about 2.5 times the Sun, which is why the text says "about half, or a bit less.")
  2. NOAA SciJinks / NESDIS, "What causes tides?" https://www.nesdis.noaa.gov/about/k-12-education/oceans-coasts/what-causes-tides (Read in full. It supplies the differential force, the stretching that makes two bulges, and the role of continents. The runners picture is this article's own and is labeled as such.)
  3. NOAA Center for Operational Oceanographic Products and Services, "Our Restless Tides." https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/restles3.html (Read in full. It supplies the sideways (tractive) part of the force, the Moon-to-Sun ratio of about 2.5, and the point that real oceans are far from an ideal smooth, water-covered Earth.)
  4. NOAA National Ocean Service, "Where is the highest tide?" https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/highesttide.html (Read in full. It places the highest tides in the Bay of Fundy and attributes large ranges to the shape of coasts. It gives no numbers for the Fundy range.)
  5. Wikipedia, "Bay of Fundy," for the range of roughly 15 to 16 meters and the open-ocean difference of roughly 1 meter (rounded in the text; a secondary source, so treat them as approximate). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bay_of_Fundy (A secondary source that cites Encyclopaedia Britannica and NOAA; those underlying pages were not read here. Treat the figures as approximate.)
  6. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "Galileo Galilei," on his theory of the tides in the Dialogue (1632). https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/galileo/ (The section on the tides was read. It describes the combination of the Earth's daily rotation and yearly revolution, the poor fit with observed tides, and Galileo's rejection of the Moon connection. The reason given in this article, a wish to avoid influences that act without contact, follows the entry's discussion of his mechanical philosophy; the entry's own wording for the rejection is harsher than this article's.)
  7. Encyclopedia of the Environment, article on tides (history of tidal theory). https://www.encyclopedie-environnement.org/en/oceans/tides/ (Read only for the history: it names Newton's Principia as the starting point of tide theory. The year 1687 is the Principia's standard publication date and does not come from this page.)

Update history

  • First published.