This site is only a doorway

Everything here is gathered from things other people actually researched, thought through, and built: books, papers, historical records, and the people behind them. If something here catches your interest, go look at the original sources listed at the bottom of the page. They carry more depth than a page like this ever can.

How Can a Whale Stay Under for More Than an Hour, Almost a Mile Down?

Category: Sea & Fishing

A Cuvier's beaked whale breathes air, just as you do. Scientists took what is known about its body, worked out how long its oxygen should last, and got an answer of about 30 minutes[2]. Then satellite tags on real whales reported ordinary hunting dives of about an hour, and about 1.4 kilometers (almost a mile) deep, again and again.

This article follows that gap between the sum and the whale. It asks where a whale keeps its oxygen, how slowly it spends it, and what the pressure of the deep does to its lungs. Along the way it keeps three things apart that are easy to blur: a typical dive, the deepest dive recorded, and the longest. It ends with what nobody has yet worked out.

1. An Ordinary Dive Lasts About an Hour, Twice What Its Oxygen Should Allow; the Records Are Separate

The Cuvier's beaked whale, sometimes called the goose-beaked whale, is a medium-sized whale about 15 to 23 feet (roughly 4.5 to 7 meters) long. It lives in most oceans and likes deep water over the edge of the continental shelf. It hunts mostly squid, and sometimes fish and crustaceans[1]. It is hard to watch from a boat, because it spends so little time at the surface. Tags are how scientists learned what it does below.

Start with the ordinary, because that is what the whale does day after day. Off Cape Hatteras, North Carolina, 23 whales were tagged, and 3,680 of their dives, presumed to be feeding dives, were studied. The median dive lasted 59 minutes, and only 5 percent lasted more than 77.7 minutes[3]. Off southern California, eight tagged whales made deep dives that averaged 1,401 meters (almost a mile, or about 4,600 feet) and 67.4 minutes, with roughly 100 minutes between deep dives on average[4]. An hour is about twice what the oxygen sum predicted[2].

The records are different things, and they were not set in one dive. The deepest dive recorded was 2,992 meters (nearly 3 km, or about 2 miles; 9,816 feet), in the California study[1][4]. The longest dive in that same study lasted 137.5 minutes, but the article does not say it was the same dive as the deepest[4].

The longest dive on record, 222 minutes (3 hours 42 minutes), came later from a single whale tagged off Cape Hatteras[1][2]. The researchers did not use it, or a 173-minute dive by the same whale, in their main analysis, because both were recorded 17 and 24 days after a known one-hour exposure to a Navy sonar signal. They suggest such records may say more about the true limit of the species[3]. So the 222 minutes is a real recording, but it is the extreme end, not a typical dive, and it was not paired with a depth.

So where does all that oxygen come from? The first place to look is the place most people would guess.

2. Deep Divers Keep Their Oxygen in Blood and Muscle, Not in the Lungs

When you take a big breath before a swim, you are loading the lungs. It feels like the obvious store of oxygen. But a physiology review by Gerald Kooyman and Paul Ponganis reports that in animals that dive deep, more than 80 percent of the oxygen store sits in the blood and the muscles[5]. Their table puts the range at 80 to 90 percent[5].

That comes from more blood, more red cells, and more hemoglobin than a land animal of the same size would have. The review also names a hallmark of animals that dive deep: a much higher concentration of myoglobin in the muscles[5]. Myoglobin is a protein that picks up oxygen and holds it inside muscle cells. A simple way to picture it is a backpack, though there is no bag: the oxygen is held on the protein itself.

A pack that full raises a new problem, though. Proteins packed this tightly can be expected to clump together.

3. A Slight Electric Charge Keeps the Oxygen-Holding Protein from Clumping

In 2013, a team led by Scott Mirceta and Michael Berenbrink compared myoglobin across living mammals. They found that the diving species, from 16-gram water shrews to 80,000-kilogram whales, share a signature: a high net electric charge on the surface of the myoglobin molecule. That charge goes along with much higher myoglobin concentrations in the muscle[6].

Why does charge matter? Molecules with the same kind of charge push each other away, like two magnets pushed together with matching ends. As one science writer put it, the extra charge lets deep divers pack myoglobin at higher concentrations without it clumping together uselessly[7]. The magnet image is only a picture: the real force is electrical, not magnetic.

The pattern is strong enough to predict with. Combining the surface charge with body mass predicts 82 percent of the variation in maximum dive time across living mammals[6]. It predicts the maximum dive time of a species, not the length of one particular dive.

4. Slow Heartbeats and Narrowed Blood Vessels Make the Stored Oxygen Last

A big account is only half the story. The other half is how slowly it is spent. In animals that dive, the heart rate drops during a dive (bradycardia) and blood vessels in less urgent tissues narrow. On very long dives, the slower heartbeat and narrowed blood vessels help save the oxygen in the blood for the brain and heart[5].

The slowdown is not the same in every dive. The review notes that the heart-rate drop during dives to depth varies, and probably depends on the nature of the dive[5]. For beaked whales, the researchers behind the 222-minute record suggest a combination: a low metabolic rate, large oxygen stores, and a high ability to handle the acid that builds up when muscles run without oxygen[3]. They describe this as a suggestion, not a measurement.

5. Under Pressure the Lungs Collapse, Which Helps Protect the Whale from the Bends

Down in the deep, water pressure squeezes the body. Divers who breathe air from a tank know a danger here: nitrogen dissolves into the blood under pressure, and if a diver rises too fast it can form bubbles, causing decompression sickness, or "the bends." In diving mammals, the review says, the lungs collapse at fairly shallow depths, which limits how much nitrogen gets absorbed. This limits how much nitrogen enters the blood and helps protect diving mammals from decompression sickness[5].

How deep is "shallow"? It depends on the animal and on how it was measured. A study of one adult female California sea lion, over 48 dives, put lung collapse at about 225 meters (give or take 25 meters). Deeper dives collapsed the lungs deeper, and about 75 percent of the variation in collapse depth was explained by the depth of the dive[8]. For Weddell and elephant seals, nitrogen measurements put collapse at roughly 20 to 50 meters, and for bottlenose dolphins about 70 meters[5].

None of these numbers comes from a beaked whale. The same review points out that it is still debated whether large whales dive with full or partial lungs[5]. What a Cuvier's beaked whale's lungs do at 2,992 meters has not been measured in the sources used here.

6. Even With All These Tricks, the Longest Recorded Dives Are Not Fully Explained

Back to the opening question. A large oxygen store in blood and muscle, a slow rate of spending, and lungs that collapse rather than fill the blood with nitrogen all help explain why these whales can stay under for an hour. They do not yet explain 222 minutes. The researchers who calculated the 30-minute limit suggest the whales may also tolerate lactic acid building up in their muscles[2].

One more puzzle: the Hatteras team found no relationship between the longest 5 percent of dives and the interval before the next deep dive, nor with the time spent breathing at the surface just before or after a long dive[3]. The idea that a longer dive simply needs a longer rest did not show up in the data. That is a gap in knowledge, and it is a good place for a curious reader to keep looking.

How to Explore a Whale's Dive Yourself

  • Measure a mile on a map. Use a map or a map app to find a place about 1.4 kilometers (almost a mile) from your home, and think about how long it would take to walk there. A typical deep dive goes that far straight down, in the dark, with no air.
  • Compare with a movie. Look up the running time of a long film. A typical dive of 59 minutes is about one television episode. Is the 222-minute record longer than the film you picked?
  • Draw the oxygen account. On a piece of paper, sketch a whale and mark the three places in sections 2 to 5: blood, muscle, and lungs. Which one gets the biggest share? Then check your drawing against the Kooyman and Ponganis review listed below.

Sources

This article is a personal summary based on the public sources listed below.

  1. NOAA Fisheries, "Cuvier's Beaked Whale" species profile. https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/species/cuviers-beaked-whale (Fetched through a summarizing tool. It supplies the length, range, diet, and the deepest (9,816 feet) and longest (222 minutes) known dives. It does not say who recorded them; the 222 minutes is matched to the Quick study through source 2. The meters figure is converted from feet.)
  2. Science News, "A beaked whale's nearly four-hour-long dive sets a new record" (September 2020). https://www.sciencenews.org/?p=3091749 (Fetched through a summarizing tool; a news report, not the paper. It supplies the 222 minutes, the earlier 137.5-minute record, the roughly 30-minute prediction from oxygen stores, the lactic acid suggestion, and the missing surface-recovery pattern. It gives 3,680 dives by 23 whales, matching source 3. Another page of search results gave 3,860, so the number is taken from the abstract.)
  3. N. J. Quick, W. R. Cioffi, J. M. Shearer, A. Fahlman and A. J. Read, "Extreme diving in mammals: first estimates of behavioural aerobic dive limits in Cuvier's beaked whales," Journal of Experimental Biology 223 (18), 2020. https://researchportal.plymouth.ac.uk/en/publications/extreme-diving-in-mammals-first-estimates-of-behavioural-aerobic-/ (The abstract and, through a fetch, the discussion passage on the extreme dives were read, not the full paper. It supplies 3,680 presumed feeding dives from 23 tags, the 59-minute median, the 77.7-minute figure for the longest 5 percent, the lack of a link with recovery time, the suggestion about metabolism, oxygen stores, and acid buffering, and the 173- and 222-minute dives recorded 17 and 24 days after a known sonar exposure and left out of the main analysis.)
  4. G. S. Schorr and colleagues, "First long-term behavioral records from Cuvier's beaked whales (Ziphius cavirostris) reveal record-breaking dives," PLoS ONE 9 (3): e92633 (2014). https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0092633 (Fetched through a summarizing tool, not read word for word. It supplies eight whales tagged off southern California, the 2,992-meter and 137.5-minute records at the time, and the deep-dive averages of 1,401 meters and 67.4 minutes with about 102 minutes between deep dives. It does not say that the deepest and longest dives were the same dive.)
  5. G. L. Kooyman and P. J. Ponganis, "The physiological basis of diving to depth: birds and mammals," Annual Review of Physiology 60 (1998). https://www.duckdna.org/syllabi/diving/readings/wk1/Kooyman-Ponganis-1998-Annu-Rev-Physiol.pdf (The text of the PDF was extracted and the passages used were read directly, but the whole review was not read. It supplies the 80 to 90 percent figure, the myoglobin hallmark, bradycardia that varies with the dive, lung collapse and nitrogen, the 20 to 50 meter and 70 meter estimates, and the open question about whales. This is a 1998 review, so newer measurements may exist.)
  6. S. Mirceta and colleagues, "Evolution of mammalian diving capacity traced by myoglobin net surface charge," Science 340 (6138), 2013. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.1234192 (Only the abstract, as quoted in a search result, was read. The journal page could not be opened. It supplies the charge signature, the range from 16-gram shrews to 80,000-kilogram whales, and the 82 percent figure.)
  7. National Geographic (Phenomena blog), "One Protein Shows Elephants and Moles Had Aquatic Ancestors" (2013). https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/one-protein-shows-elephants-and-moles-had-aquatic-ancestors (Fetched through a summarizing tool; a news report on the Mirceta study. It supplies the plain-language explanation that the charge makes molecules repel one another so they do not clump.)
  8. "Lung collapse in diving sea lions" (PubMed Central), a study of a California sea lion. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3497143/ (Fetched through a summarizing tool. It supplies one adult female, 48 dives, collapse near 225 plus or minus 25 meters measured from oxygen pressure in the aorta, and the 75 percent figure. It is a sea lion study, not a whale study.)

Update history

  • First published.
  • Title, section 1 and section 6: separated the typical dive, the deepest dive and the 222-minute record, and added that the 222-minute dive was recorded after a sonar exposure. Reason: the first title joined the depth record and the duration record as if they were one dive.