This site is only a doorway

Everything here is gathered from things other people actually researched, thought through, and built: books, papers, historical records, and the people behind them. If something here catches your interest, go look at the original sources listed at the bottom of the page. They carry more depth than a page like this ever can.

How Do Corals With No Brain All Release Their Eggs on the Same Night?

Category: Living Things

Once a year, on a few nights after a full moon, a coral reef does something astonishing. Colony after colony lets go of its eggs and sperm, all within about an hour of each other. Corals have no brain, no eyes to speak of, and no calendar on the wall. So how does a whole reef agree on the night?

The short answer is that corals read light, and in at least one species the key signal seems to be a stretch of darkness between sunset and moonrise. But that leaves a bigger question: what about nights when clouds hide the Moon? Later sections follow that question to a midge that counts days and to small shore animals that keep a tide clock of their own.

1. Many corals release eggs and sperm on one night, so that they can find each other

Most reef-building corals are "broadcast spawners": they let eggs and sperm go into the open water, where they have to meet. On the Great Barrier Reef off Australia, more than 130 coral species spawn on the same night, in a window of roughly 30 to 60 minutes[1]. Corals stay fixed in one place, so a colony cannot go looking for a partner. If every colony picked its own day, eggs and sperm would drift apart in the huge ocean. Releasing together is thought to raise the chances of fertilization[1].

The authors of one study call this one of the best examples of synchronized behavior on Earth[1]. It also shows up elsewhere. A Japanese-Taiwanese research team notes that in many places corals spawn around the full moon of early summer[2].

Season is set mostly by the sea getting warmer, which the same study names as the likely driver for ripening eggs and sperm[1]. But warmth alone cannot pick one night out of many. Something else has to point to the date.

2. Corals seem to read the light at night, and one study found the signal is a gap of darkness, not the Moon itself

The obvious suspect is moonlight, and there is evidence for it. In 2015, a team studied the coral Acropora millepora from the Great Barrier Reef. They gave corals different light treatments and sampled them before, during, and after spawning. Light changed gene activity linked to releasing eggs and sperm, and those changes appeared only on the night of spawning. When the corals were given light meant to mimic city light pollution, some of their cell signaling went out of step and they did not spawn. The authors conclude that moonlight is an important outside signal for synchrony[1].

A different experiment suggests a twist. In 2021, researchers working with the coral Dipsastraea speciosa at Green Island, Taiwan, covered corals at night to block moonlight. Uncovered corals spawned six nights after the full moon. Corals covered from three days before, one day before, or one day after the full moon each spawned five nights after the covers went on. So taking away night light moved spawning earlier, which means moonlight was holding spawning back, not calling for it[2].

Which light mattered? Tank tests with lamps showed that light in the first half of the night was what held spawning back. And when there was a dark stretch between the end of daylight and the start of night light, the holding-back effect disappeared[2].

Here is where the 50 minutes from the tides comes back. The Moon rises about 50 minutes later each day on average (the exact delay varies with the place and the date), so before the full moon it rises before sunset and its light follows straight on from the sunlight. After the full moon it rises after sunset, and a dark gap opens up in the evening. The researchers propose that this gap, which grows as moonrise slides later, is the corals' cue[2]. You can read the same 50-minute shift in why high tide comes about 50 minutes later each day.

The two studies look different on the surface: one stresses moonlight as a trigger, the other says moonlight is a brake and darkness is the go signal. They tested different corals under different conditions, so they may not be in direct conflict. Both agree that light at night matters and that artificial light can disturb it. Other things matter too. Temperature, tides, and the times of sunrise and sunset are also named as influences[1].

So a coral can read an outside cue. But many animals keep their dates even when the sky is cloudy or when they live where the Moon cannot be seen. Do they carry a calendar inside?

3. A tiny sea midge keeps a calendar inside its body, and it seems to work by counting days

Many sea animals time their lives by the tides, and the biggest tides come around full moon and new moon. Researchers have found body clocks that follow moon-related cycles, called circalunar (about a month) or circasemilunar (about two weeks) clocks, in algae, jellyfish relatives, worms, mollusks, crustaceans, insects, and fish[3]. The inner workings are mostly unknown. In more than 20 species with such a clock, researchers have tested how it works in only four[3].

One of those is a marine midge, Clunio marinus, a small insect of rocky shores. Its adults come out on a roughly two-week schedule. Three ideas had been proposed for how such a clock might work: a built-in 15-day oscillator, a counter that tallies days, or a "beat" produced when a daily rhythm and a tidal rhythm overlap[3].

A 2024 study put the midge in the lab with no Moon at all and changed the length of its "day". When researchers stretched the day-night cycle, the two-week rhythm stretched with it in a straight line. That fits a day-counting clock. When they used a 6-hours-light, 6-hours-dark cycle, the rhythm was about the same as with a normal 12:12 cycle, which suggests it follows the animal's own daily clock and not the outside light cycle. And when constant light threw the daily clock out of order, the two-week rhythm vanished too[3].

That goes against the long-held view that this midge's two-week clock runs independently of its daily clock[3]. Still, it is one insect. The authors suggest that the moon-related clocks of flies and mosquitoes may work on different principles than those of marine worms and algae, and that such clocks may have evolved more than once[3].

A clock that counts days could keep a two-week beat. But the sea itself rises and falls twice a day. Is there a clock for that?

4. Some shore animals keep a tide clock of about 12.4 hours that runs even without any tide

High tides come about 12.4 hours apart. Scientists call a body rhythm of this length a circatidal rhythm[4]. Some shore animals keep following it in a tank with no tides.

The best-studied case is a tiny crustacean, Eurydice pulchra, from European beaches. A 2013 study found that its swimming rose and fell on a cycle of about 12.4 hours in constant conditions, could be reset by suitable stimuli, and did not speed up or slow down with temperature. Those are the three tests used to decide whether something is a true biological clock. When the researchers disrupted the genes of the animal's daily clock, its tidal timing was not affected. They concluded that it has a dedicated tide pacemaker, separate from its daily clock[4].

Another example comes from Japan. A cricket that lives on the floor of mangrove forests, Apteronemobius asahinai, stays active on a 12.6-hour cycle when conditions are held constant. It also has a daily rhythm, being more active at subjective night. Researchers found 284 genes whose activity rose and fell on a cycle of 12 to 15 hours, and they note that their sampling was small and the results are a first step[5].

Whether a tide clock and a daily clock are really separate machines is still debated. Different animals may have solved the problem in different ways[4][5]. So the reef's answer has three layers: corals read outside light cues, a midge counts days inside its body, and some shore animals tick along with the tides. None of these is a brain, and each one does a job that a calendar would do for us.

How to look for these rhythms yourself

  • Track moonrise. Find a free moonrise table for your town and write down the time of moonrise for ten nights in a row. Does it slip by about 50 minutes a day? On which night does moonrise move from before sunset to after sunset?
  • Match it to the tides. Put a tide table beside your moonrise notes. Both slide by a similar amount each day. Which one changes more evenly?
  • Notice night light. Look at how bright the sky is near your home after dark. Researchers worry that light pollution may confuse corals, and they suggest that reducing artificial light near reefs could help[1]. What light could be turned off near you?
  • Visit a shore carefully. If you go to a beach or tide pool, go with an adult, check the tide times first, and look without picking up or moving the animals. Small shore animals may be running a clock you cannot see.
  • Read the original. The eLife paper on coral spawning has a short plain-language summary at the top. Read it and compare it with this article.

Sources

This article is a personal summary based on the public sources listed below.

  1. Kaniewska P., Alon S., Karako-Lampert S., Hoegh-Guldberg O., Levy O. (2015), "Signaling cascades and the importance of moonlight in coral broadcast mass spawning," eLife. https://elifesciences.org/articles/09991 (The abstract, the plain-language digest, and the introduction were read; the results sections were not read in full. The 130 species, the 30 to 60 minute window, the role of warming sea temperature, the other cues, and the light-pollution result come from these parts.)
  2. Lin C.-H., Takahashi S., Mulla A. J., Nozawa Y. (2021), "Moonrise timing is key for synchronized spawning in coral Dipsastraea speciosa," Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, doi:10.1073/pnas.2101985118. Read through the Japanese press release of the University of the Ryukyus. https://www.u-ryukyu.ac.jp/news/26432/ (The release, in Japanese, was read in full. It describes the shading experiments at Green Island, the tank tests, the first-half-of-night result, and the moonrise-gap idea. The paper itself was not read, so the details come second-hand. The "gap" is the authors' proposal; the release says that how it triggers spawning, and how widely it applies to other corals, are still being studied.)
  3. Neumann and colleagues (2024), study of the circasemilunar clock of the marine midge Clunio marinus and its link to the circadian clock, open-access paper in PubMed Central (PMC11292968). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11292968/ (The abstract and the first part of the introduction were read through the NCBI text service, because the main page blocked automated access. The T-cycle, 6:6, and constant-light results, the three hypotheses, the list of animal groups, and the "more than 20 species, four tested" count come from there. The count and the list are cited in the paper to a 2021 review by Kaiser and Neumann, which was not read here.)
  4. Zhang L. et al. (2013), study of the circatidal clock of the intertidal crustacean Eurydice pulchra, Current Biology, open-access paper in PubMed Central (PMC3793863). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3793863/ (The summary and the start of the introduction were read through the NCBI text service. The 12.4-hour swimming rhythm, the three clock criteria, and the conclusion of a dedicated tide pacemaker come from the summary. Details of the methods were not read.)
  5. Study of rhythmic gene activity in the mangrove cricket Apteronemobius asahinai, open-access paper in PubMed Central (PMC6403293). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6403293/ (The abstract and the first part of the introduction were read through the NCBI text service. The 12.6-hour cycle, the subjective-night activity, the 284 genes with cycles of 12 to 15 hours, and the authors' note about limited sampling come from there.)

Update history

  • First published.